Non-Meltable

Showing 1–36 of 59 results

• 

  Caramel Dip Tubs

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $6.29
• 

  Caramel Apple Kits

  $7.95
• 

  Mix-n-Match Caramels

  $7.47 – $31.80
• 
  Gift Wrap Available

  Assorted Caramels

  $7.95 – $34.50
• 

  Caramel Apple Caramels

  $14.50 – $49.56
• 

  Pumpkin Pie Caramels

  $14.50 – $49.56
• 

  Licorice Caramels

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $7.95 – $49.56
• 

  Sea Salt Caramels

  $7.95 – $49.56
• 

  Chocolate & Vanilla Caramels

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $14.50 – $49.56
• 

  Vanilla Walnut Caramels

  $7.95 – $49.56
• 

  Butter Rum Caramels

  $14.50 – $49.56
• 

  Pecan Caramel Nougat Caramels

  $7.95 – $49.56
• 

  Chocolate Caramels

  $14.50 – $49.56
• 

  Pecan Alligator® Caramels

  $14.50 – $49.56
• 

  Vanilla Caramels (14 pc)

  $6.99
• 

  Sugar Free Vanilla Caramels

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $15.75 – $54.60
• 

  Sugar Free Chocolate Vanilla Caramels

  $15.75 – $54.60
• 

  Sea Salt Caramels (14 pc)

  $6.99
• 

  Bourbon Butter Caramels

  $7.25
• 

  Old Fashion Butter Caramels

  $7.25
• 

  Old Fashioned Butter & Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels

  $7.25
• 

  Vanilla Caramels (12 pc)

  $7.47
• 

  Chocolate & Vanilla Caramels (14 pc)

  $6.99
• 

  Licorice Jelly Beans

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $5.95
• 

  Pectin Fruit Jelly Beans

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $6.95
• 

  Sanded Lemon Drops

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $4.95
• 

  Sanded Licorice Drops

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $4.95
• 

  Sanded Root Beer Drops

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $4.95
• 

  Sanded Wild Cherry Drops

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $4.95
• 

  Sour Cherry Balls

  $6.25
• 

  Spice Jelly Beans

  $5.95
• 

  Pecan Caramel Nougat Caramels (14 pc)

  $6.99
• 

  Royal Almonds

  Rated 5.00 out of 5
  $8.95
• 

  Butterscotch Buttons

  $6.25
• 

  Candy Jar Mix

  $6.25
• 

  Butter Rum Caramels (14 pc)

  $6.99